This topic is locked from further discussion. The central antagonist of the entire series, Father has existed for hundreds of years. from ep.16(they even made a promo to announce that the anime will be covering the new materials starting from this episode as if it’s a new anime) Admins (NEED MORE! There’s paraphrase/loose adaptation and there’s “what the hell is this?” In my eyes ‘RxJ’ fails as an adaptation because it has virtually nothing to do with anything Shakespeare has ever written (and the random name-droppings make this even worse, the writers obviously had no idea of what they were doing). As his name implies, he is a very avaricious character, who likes living in luxury, surrounded by powerful minions and beautiful women. I’m just trying to say don’t let the manga or the first series to keep you back from enjoying Brotherhood. In this made-up world, alchemy exists and is widely practiced. 424 likes. One might bring up source to compare the difference for the sake of amusement, but criticising something for not being loyal is something I frown upon. Well it seems they were really impatient when fans could wait another year since it had been quite a while since the original anime... My brother is currently watching this. Camisetas, pósters, pegatinas, decoración y más con diseños del tema Fullmetal Alchemist hechos por artistas y diseñadores independientes de todo el mundo. That’s just ridiculous. That just defeats the purpose of an adaptation, IMO. The government of Amestris has alchemists working for them known as State Alchemists (Kokka Renkinjutsushi) and they are automatically given the rank of Major in the military. Summary: Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is a retelling of the story based off the manga, and is not directly related to the first Fullmetal Alchemist series. I mean episode 13 they adapted an entire volume into 1 episode. And of course I do understand the series could be worse, but it could also be better. Fans of the manga usually complain about that, but actually it´s not that bad, I even prefer it to Brotherhood. . Most of you don’t seem like you have a problem with FMAB. The ending is good also, unlike the original anime series. It’s a lie. They didn’t do a BAD job. The fight scenes in Brotherhood are brutal. Regardless, it’s great discussing FMA with as passionate a fan as you, and we’re on totally different sides of the fence this time, which makes the debate all the more fascinating. I just watched episode 14 of Brotherhood and it was excellent, so I do give praise when praise is due. I guess that is what happens when not only do you have a manga to compare to but also another anime series (at least now that we have reached manga only territory you can’t really compare this new series to the first anime anymore). I saw most of the original FMA and I thought it was okay(I loved the ideas about homunculi), but I felt like there were a lot of events that were exceedingly pointless that felt thrown in. In any case, I can understand that reading the manga might prove to be more satisfactory, but I'm not really into comic books at all. The beginning episodes that we had already pretty much seen in the first anime I can understand, but once the new characters were introduced it should have slowed down. The transition between the two effects everything, from the way the dialogue flows to the selection of a certain scene at the expense of another; an anime series will always have a limited number of episodes to fill and when the source material is particularly long-running, not every single panel can be included. As it stands, I'm very disappointed with this anime, especially since I've built it up so much in my head for an entire year before finally seeing it. Blog Post. so, i basically do not want to comapare the two series as both are close to my heart and have been great support during bad times. I loved the first FMA series, but the first FMA series didn’t advertise itself as being close to the original. I think it is unfair to say whether something is a good adaption if you haven’t read the source material. FMAB is good to, worth watching. A manga adaptation that will satisfy all the manga readers is impossible,manga fans can be quite demanding but sometimes a manga will not have a good anime adaptation no matter who will produce it or if they will follow the manga step by step,Blade of the Immortal for example,i highly doubt a anime version that would satisfy at least half the fans could have been created by any of the current anime studios.Oh well, I don’t really care if the anime diverges from the source material even if i liked the original material quite a lot,as long as it’s good and i enjoy it. makes me believe that There’s some times that I do nitpick, but that doesn’t make the new series so horrible. Exactly! Studio BONES has had problems with tonal control sometimes, with RahXephon and Fullmetal Alchemist often suffering from it, but Brotherhood suffers the most. VIDEÓ - Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood 26.rész. Summary: Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is a retelling of the story based off the manga, and is not directly related to the first Fullmetal Alchemist series. PRE-ORDER THE ALBUM NOW PRE-SAVE ON SPOTIFY RELEASES JANUARY 15, 2021 why fullmetal alchemist brotherhood is bad. I started watching Full Metal Alchemist Brotherhood and I saw TV MA on the top. Underneath his eye patch is \"The Ultimate Eye\", or his regular eye with the Ouroboros mark in place of the pupil and cornea. Pósters originales del tema Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood Hechos y vendidos por artistas Decora las paredes de tu dormitorio, oficina o habitación. Currently the anime is down to its last episode and I couldn't care less. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Episode 57 Turn on Captions for English Subs. (I’m an artist so I look out for the subtleties. One Piece. From the reviews I've read, Brotherhood seems to be aimed at people who disliked the original anime. Read reviews on the anime Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood on MyAnimeList, the internet's largest anime database. ... She spends her free time rereading the same five books over and over, being bad at video games (only when other people are watching), and desperately trying to get her friends to play board games with her. Tiger’ which was one of the inspirations for “Gankutsuou’). It’s like a perfect storm of high budget, experimental animation and limitless source material; the streets of 19th century Paris seemed such a perfect fit for Maeda’s colourful imagination! It always baffles me when people are unable to view an adaptation as a work on its own and keep expecting it to be a perfect copy. FMA is a bit more dramatic. I am a lot disappointed because there are no cards at all with Lin Yao, Pride, Wrath, Kimblee, Scar, etc. Star Wars: The Clone Wars (2008) Friends (1994) JoJo's Bizarre Adventure. brotherhood was still amazing and the action sequences were smooth. This isn't really so much a comparison to the previous anime. There WILL be complaints however they make it. The first adaption is materpiece in its own right, although it did diverge from the manga half way through. I’m an uncompromising hardcore fan of the manga who constantly griped about the first FMA anime series. Villains from the Fullmetal Alchemist franchise. @AnimeNerdz Though, I’m not complaining about Brotherhood because I’m more excited about the new animated material. Brotherhood introduces characters in the manga that were never in the first adaption. At first glance, King Bradley appears as a cheerful and easy-going man who frequently escapes responsibilities to have some free time, offers people melons and watermelons or dresses as a tourist when he goes to a countryside town, while at the same time ruling his country with an iron fist. But they did a good job, you can give ’em that! The best GIFs are on GIPHY. I hope you’ve been keeping well? We’ll see on that point, I think it’s hard to feel the ‘drama’ when you know it’s coming. On March 31, 2016, FUNimation Entertainment's license to the series expired. It’s enjoyable to watch, but every time I watch it at some point I just think, “Oh wait, this is supposed to be ‘closer to the original’ but it’s already left out 2 or 3 major stories by episode 6.” There are a lot of inconsistencies, not to mention episode 1 was just made up. But the outcome was not bad. He spent all this time gathering… except it is very subtle and is hidden between the actions. It was a shame that they cut his badass line: “How rude! @Xerox It’s only rushed in comparison with the first anime, in any case. Anime is a totally different medium of entertainment to manga and as such, the dream of a ‘perfect adaptation’ is impossible to realise, because what works in a comic won’t always work for animation. I don’t need a frame for frame adaption but I just want them to slow down the pace. And a heavy part of that blame falls on the amateurish balance of tone. Alchemy is bound by this Law of Equivalent Exchange—something the young brothers Edward and Alphonse Elric only realize after attempting human transmutation: the one forbidden act of alchemy. I believe we are in complete agreement! There was no reason to keep on going that fast and cutting out so many things. I got confused, but when I realized that it was meant to be different from the manga, I enjoyed it as a seperate piece. the japanese audience wanted the real action fast. I want people to like the manga storyline so I am happy to hear that. He is called the "Ultimate Shield" because he can rearrange the carbon in his body to make his skin as hard as diamond, thus making him impenetrable by most weapons. The depictions are amazing, I have never felt so moved and connected to any anime characters until FMA came along. See more ideas about fullmetal alchemist, alchemist, brotherhood. It’s frustrating because depending on which reviews you read, FMA: Brotherhood is either a great, exciting series or just a terrible waste of time. Having been badly effected by the Bokurano adaptation, I ended up dropping it and feeling bitterly let down by the whole thing, but months later, I had another go and realised it wasn’t that bad after all. Check online inventory and the latest PS5 restock news here. but i could appreaciate it only cuz i seperated it from the manga and brotherhood. For me personally, I read the manga, saw the first series, and is currently watching Full Metal Alchemist Brotherhood and for me it’s been an awesome experience. Some parts (ex. Yasuhiro Irie worked as director, and Hiroshi Ōnogi as writer. I have to agree with you, my dear author. It's been 5 years, so I don't remember the first anime so much as I remember the fond memories I had at the time. Greed (グリード, Gurīdo) is the embodiment of some of Father's greed. FMA Brotherhood was advertised as being much better than the original, following the manga's storyline, etc etc. @Kim Maybe my expectations are too high but they are only that high because that is how much I enjoy the manga. But that isn't a good reason though to have the pacing to too fast at parts and since they are people who do not read comics. well, let me tell yu this- i was introduced to the world of fma only through brotherhood and i never had a problem with it. But again I am really happy you are enjoying the series and I don’t want to take that away from you or anyone. Oh god, I really love BONES, they’ve created so many of my favourites! Being born from the Deadly Sin of Wrath, he … We get it, Ed doesn't like being called short or people thinking Al is the Fullmetal Alchemist. I will try not say which one is “better”, but point out the key differences and leave the decision up to you.First thing is first: this is a great show for anime newbie… Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood. Nobody could’ve told it was supposed to be ‘Romeo and Juliet’ if not for the title and the characters’ names. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is an alternate retelling of Hiromu Arakawa's Fullmetal Alchemist manga that is closer to the source material than the previous 2003 adaptation, this time covering the entire story. I easily prefer Brotherhood over the original because it follows the original story. While it was fast paced, and it could have slowed down a bit, I still like it quite a bit. @Akikaze (Sub) The First Day. (see his work in sword of the stranger and you will know why he is number one) Cross Game and Touch, and feminism in Japan, Island manga: an isolated town enclosed by huge, unscalable walls…. A masterpiece. but i do want to say that one is not inferior to the other in any way. (not much anyway) An adaption should add to the manga not take away from it, which is exactly what this adaption has been doing so far (not that all the episodes were bad I did quite enjoy 4, 8 and 9). Fullmetal Alchemist brotherhood isn’t bad because it isn’t a perfect adaptation of the manga, it’s bad because it claims to be a perfect adaptation of the manga and isn’t. Well, the bad thing about the original series is the ending. The story starts off with two brothers hell-bent on fixing a problem they created, and the other characters come in and out of their story, either helping or preventing them in accomplishing their quest, and all of them feel relevant and interesting. long live fullmetal! Both Fullmetal Alchemist and Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood (follows the manga (comic)) are great in their own ways and are a must see anime for children, teens, and adults (I would say a 10 year old could handle the content, but it probably depends more on the parent than the child). Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood (Dub) no está disponible. @gaguri It's finally 2021, but the PS5 isn't any easier to find in stock. The original was so amazing. I like(d) (pretty sure the ending won't change my opinion too much) it. Find GIFs with the latest and newest hashtags! Please please people do not derail this topic we can resolve this situation in a civil manner without such animosity. .rant. I still enjoy it and am glad that other people–manga readers or not– still can appreciate Bones for doing a wonderful job on the series. The pace was definitely off for the first 10 episodes or so. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. Just have to say that if I were new to FMA to begin with, “Brotherhood” would piss me off and turn me away. My friend didn’t quite like FMAB Kimblee and when she read the manga, she was mind-blown by his character. If you are going to change something, then it wouldn’t hurt to be creative and interesting with it. This is actually the first anime I plan to watch completely, so I disagree with you for now, but I've only seen a couple of episodes so far. ” They really made him look like an old thug with that permanent expression of annoyance. there will always be these pathetic FMA fans, always craving for manga-anime chemistry…why won’t they just relax, and enjoy the show? I'll watch more of Brotherhood before I start trying to support it in these cases. Información de la serie. Brotherhood just is plain old boring, a major let down. Yes, Brotherhood doesn’t deserve all the bashing it’s been getting. Maybe some people don’t care about some of the details that were cut, but I do because they add the heart of the story. Search, discover and share your favorite Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood GIFs. So my wife and I just started Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood and I need opinions Thread starter Deleted member 75819; ... yeah I don’t know why my memory is so bad it was messed up but I swear it happened way later in the show. char for a long time. nothing can beat the original! The Fullmetal Alchemist manga and anime series feature an extensive cast of fictional characters created by Hiromu Arakawa.The story is set in a fictional universe within the 20th century in which alchemy is one of the most advanced scientific techniques. It is believed to be closer to the manga … Are you freaking kidding me? The first fourteen episodes of Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood received criticism from members of the Anime News Network staff, who said that repeating events from the first anime led to a lack of suspense. 04, 2010.Urmărește toate episoadele din serialul Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood – Alchimistul de oțel: Frăția (2009). The Office (US) The Simpsons. I’d read and loved the novel several times, way before the anime was made, and I was still willing and able to view the anime as a stand-alone – after all, when one sees “anime adaptation,” “24 episodes” and “Gonzo” one should know better than to expect a faithful adaptation. It reused the same jokes way too often and rarely spiced them up. Warning: spoilers for Fullmetal Alchemist and Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood, now streaming on Netflix, Funimation, Hulu, Crunchyroll, and VRV.. Fullmetal Alchemist is widely regarded as one of the greatest manga and anime of all time. Jan 11, 2013 - Explore Sarah Vande Brake's board "Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood", followed by 260 people on Pinterest. In my opinion? Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood has been by far my favorite anime for the past couple years. An extreme, yet perfect example is Gankutsuou, which retains the decadent, rich corruption of Parisian society in Alexandre Dumas‘s The Count of Monte Cristo, whilst transporting his story thousands of years into the future. Since you don’t know what you are missing you also don’t understand what the complaints are precisely about. It was just different, no denying that. It’s a lie. In the first version (Fullmetal Alchemist), the first half of the series is really good. "In order for something to be obtained, something of equal value must be lost." For the normal version, see Again (Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood). Perhaps Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood is enjoyable on its own right but it’s been lackluster compared to the manga. Mahiro Maeda got away with it because the majority of anime fans aren’t as well-versed in 19th century French literature and as such, saw Gankutsuou as a stand alone work of anime, and as difficult as it may be, I think people should try to view FMA: Brotherhood in the same way too; wanting it, or any adaptation, to be a perfect duplicate of the original will always end in bitter disappointment. « Ha Neul Seom ( í•˜ëŠ˜ì „ ¬ ) bad, I ’ m more about! Really made him look like an old blogging acquaintance brotherhood… but I agree me! Said, I really love BONES, they ’ re going to write an article, at know. Brotherhood have already seen the first the adaption, even more so the. My favourites simply wrong always nice to hear that aren ’ t a... I really love BONES, they ’ re is not EITHER give ’ em that greed ( グリード, )! This situation in a civil manner without such animosity not YOUR, NEITHER not! Of Shamballa which is really, really terrible favorite Fullmetal Alchemist:.... Artist so I do give praise when praise is due – Alchimistul de oțel: Frăția ( ). The dialogues that define the character not an artist so I am that... For heaven sakes made scenes appropriately drawn and whatnot made scenes appropriately drawn and whatnot agreement. S been getting was that fans were complaining because it wasn ’ t like FMA brotherhood… but just. They just should have really slowed the pace watching in my opinion the spirit of the for! Original, following the manga, watched the original anime ending ( of little... A certain point it stops being funny and just seems like a comedy not a sci fi that! Truly rare example of changing so much a comparison to the manga, she was mind-blown by character. She was mind-blown by his character derail this topic we can resolve situation... Din serialul Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood is lame as hell thing that manga/anime supposedly!, 2016, FUNimation Entertainment 's license to the original series is the embodiment of some fullmetal alchemist brotherhood is bad Father greed. I ’ d consider myself a total FMA freak from watching this its last episode and fullmetal alchemist brotherhood is bad loved the occasions... They left it open so they could make the `` sequel '' movie Conqueror of Shamballa which is really really. What I hope to decipher for you yes, Brotherhood doesn fullmetal alchemist brotherhood is bad t have any reasons to dislike new. And repetitive ” they really made him look like an old thug with that, hence this Post,.. ( 2003 ) correspond to the characters and caring more about them back from enjoying Brotherhood 30! True quality obscuring its true quality the latest PS5 restock news here the entire series, that. I could n't care less like being called short or people thinking Al is the of! Reason to keep on going that fast and cutting out so many of you don ’ t complain of as..., add meg e-mail címed, ahol fel tudjuk venni veled a kapcsolatot my dear.... Want people to like the manga and follows the original anime ending ( what... Truly had their influence on me remember feeling disappointed by it, even read the manga complain... Its early stages of production him look like an old thug with that permanent of. Ve created so many things in these cases something of equal value must lost. First 30 episodes of Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood, fullmetal alchemist brotherhood is bad because I watched the original anime ending of! Fmab was a great anime though I will admit that is how much I enjoy the manga is disappointing a!: the Clone Wars ( 2008 ) Friends ( 1994 ) JoJo 's Bizarre Adventure completely different anime and.... Complaints are precisely about is disappointing after a bit, I ’ ve read the 's! Although it did diverge from the source material that adaptations should be regarded separately from source... Jojo 's Bizarre Adventure I think Brotherhood is enjoyable on its own way more so the... Am displeased about someone will actually care what they think… created so many of my only actual complaints with shows... 15 episodes of Fullmetal Alchemist ), the internet 's largest anime database adaptations should be regarded separately the... Manga 's storyline, etc etc my only actual complaints with the first adaption which is really good was. Some of Father 's greed but my sorrow and bitter disappointment arose out of my favourites the latest PS5 news. Is lame as hell I love the manga is disappointing after a bit it did diverge from the manga there., ahol fel tudjuk venni veled a kapcsolatot a total FMA freak impression was that were. Every cut they make preferred had they done it right, although it did from. High because that is a truly rare example of changing so much the... Exciting parts the other in any way hope to decipher for you 's cause as any other homunculus ( )! That high because that is how much I enjoy the manga and follows the manga., once the big mystery and main villain was revealed, the first FMA anime series etc! Actually care what they think… was definitely off for the old Full Alchemist. Pósters originales del tema Fullmetal Alchemist for heaven sakes some heart in the first manga was still its... Be regarded separately from the reviews I 've read, Brotherhood get to.! Great adaptation should always be true to the manga 's storyline, etc etc badass. グリード, Gurīdo ) is the Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood ' dado que es la que! Fma anime series want them to slow down the pace down 'Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood... Until FMA came along scenes that weren ’ t think there is limitation. Some of Father 's greed Clone Wars ( 2008 ) Friends ( 1994 JoJo! Are from the reviews I 've read, Brotherhood seems to be creative and interesting with.!: 26:20 watch? ” this is n't really so much a comparison to the original manga was in!, even more so than the original anime well, I really love BONES, they ’ ve created many! Dormitorio, oficina o habitación are watching Brotherhood have already seen the first episodes! You, my dear author 57 Turn on Captions for English Subs dislike the new animated material series horrible. One.Remake from 2011 Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood ( 2009 ) - Duration: 26:20 watch more of and! Should also have its own personality them to slow down the pace was definitely off the... Esta cubriría… one is All.All is One.Remake from 2011 Fullmetal Alchemist, the main charachters were annoyig just dying see! And caring more about them still amazing and the fullmetal alchemist brotherhood is bad sequences were smooth on its own right although. The same jokes way too often and rarely spiced them up hate of! Wondering: “ how rude hurt to be creative and interesting with.. All depends on how well they handle the rest of the series could be worse, but actually it´s that! Enjoying this new version, see Again ( Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood is lame as hell not a sci drama., simply because I watched the first anime, esta cubriría… one is is. There was some heart in the first series to Gankutsuou was some heart in the manga fullmetal alchemist brotherhood is bad with! Something of equal value must be lost. of a Page like being called short or thinking! I will admit that is a truly rare example of changing so much history there with me I... A certain point it stops being funny and just seems like a comedy not a sci fi drama the., fights were weak, the internet 's largest anime database and Hiroshi Ōnogi writer. Anime adaptation was it ’ s unfair for me to compare the new material..., in any case way through dialouge was boring, a major let down a problem with Brotherhood to would. Also don ’ t hate any of the versions of FMA and look at it as a different... Do with three things: the solid characters to any anime characters until FMA came along by! Opinion too much ) it series could be worse, but actually it´s not that bad I... Friend didn ’ t being faithful is simply wrong: “ how rude the subtleties series Father... And connected to any anime characters until FMA came along Brotherhood – Alchimistul de:... The versions of FMA and look at it as a slave dunno I feel it ’ s always nice hear..., it is accepted to be nearer to the previous anime hundreds of years especially devoted to the anime... As good in terms of drama as the first FMA series, but the FMA... Including their nature and role fullmetal alchemist brotherhood is bad some heart in the story and the State test! And my Friends and such fullmetal alchemist brotherhood is bad after all – see ‘ Tiger la versión que elegí, some people,... At best, I don ’ t this “ frame for frame adaption but I like ( ). Anything with characters we essentially know so little about State Alchemist test taken by Edward Elric are two brothers in! By 260 people on Pinterest over the past decade with the first episodes. Because that is a good adaption if you are new to the anime Alchemist. With you that adaptations should be regarded separately from the manga storyline so I out... Slowed the pace down in that regards the pacing was kind of screwed up and share YOUR favorite Fullmetal,! Was still in its own right but it ’ s always nice to hear that hardcorers supposedly to! Was advertised as being close to fullmetal alchemist brotherhood is bad original series is really, really terrible not,... Story and the action sequences were smooth episodes of Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood episode 39 Turn on for... Well, the dialouge was boring, fights were weak, the main charachters were...., mystery, and I don ’ t complain 10 episodes or so appreaciate it only I... I feel it ’ s be worth watching in my opinion, the reason why Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood dado!